Neighbourhood plan-based refusal overturned

The High Court has overturned Eric Pickles’ attempt to refuse 120 homes plus a care home in Sussex on the grounds of conflict with an emerging neighbourhood plan.

Mr Pickles upheld the refusal by Mid-Sussex District Council of the plan by Woodcock Holdings for the mostly greenfield 5.85ha site at Sayers Common.

An inspector recommended approval, but while the communities secretary accepted the plan on locational and economic grounds and, in principle, housing grounds, he gave significant weight to the emerging plan.

“While he appreciates that the remaining stages through which the NP has to pass may show that more land needs to be allocated, he considers that it would be inappropriate to prejudge that at this stage,” said his decision.

The developer challenged the decision on four grounds and Mr Justice Holgate upheld all four.

The Court agreed Mr Pickles had wrongly given significant weight to the site not being identified in the draft neighbourhood plan.

The judgement says his reliance on lack of an objective housing need assessment to increase the weight given to the draft plan only served to demonstrate he failed to take account of the argument there should be no such cap.

It agreed paragraphs 14 and 49 of the NPPF should have been applied to the draft and that the communities secretary had misapplied a prematurity test.  Brownfield Briefing

….. [“The title should really be “Draft Neighbourhood Plan- based refusal overturned”. Part of the problem was that it wasn’t finished when Eric Pickles overturned the inspector.”]

2 thoughts on “Neighbourhood plan-based refusal overturned

  1. The title should really be “Draft Neighbourhood Plan- based refusal overturned”. Part of the problem was that it wasn’t finished when Eric Pickles overturned the inspector.

    Ken

  2. True, but it was practically complete. It had reached the Examination stage. Looks like Eric Pickles has been playing politics with the neighbourhood plans to encourage their uptake in the absence of so many Local Plans being ratified. Let’s see what Greg has to offer…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s